pump vs semi auto shotgun recoil

There is a reduction in recoil with the gas system of the 11-87 so that is a plus for it. The Pointer 3.5 Max 5 Camo is a great versatile shotgun. Pump is new and the semi is like new and only like 40 bucks more and is camo. The main difference between Pump Action Shotgun and Semi-Auto Shotgun is that Pump Action shotguns do not necessitate any additional attention or maintenance. Gas guns have one huge advantage over all other shotguns: reduced felt recoil. Pumps can handle the reduced recoil rounds that might cause a gas operated gun to jam. semi-auto: 20: $999: $750: Benelli: M2 Field Compact: semi-auto: 12, 20 . Pump-Action Shotgun Disadvantages . 10. Re: Slug accuracy: pump vs. semi-auto? Shells are different and have more effect. i have a remington 870, and the recoil isnt at all unplesant. The Maxus is the softest shooting semi auto shotgun but not by lightyears over the 930. It's a 12-gauge with a 3-inch chamber, 18.5-inch barrel length, 6.3lbs weight, and a 5+1 capacity. Pump Action Shotgun vs Semi-Auto Shotgun. The Mossberg 500 and and the new wide range of mag fed shotguns are also popular choices. Asgard defense shotgun mfg photo. Unfamiliar with the Dickenson Commando. Shotgun Quad Load with Keanu This is a common suggestion for people who have found the 12 gauge to be too uncomfortable to shoot. Looking at recoil charts and calculators, you can see that dropping weight down around 5 pounds increases recoil . Switch to 20 Gauge. A good, top tier semi is going to run at least double if not three or four times as much. This is great weapon to shoot and provides some great power for bird hunting or pig hunting. That sound, directed at anyone, will cause them to clench to the point . A discussion and demonstration of the pump shotgun and the semi-automatic shotgun. The 1100/11-87 series are heavy guns with a gas system that reduces recoil noticeably more than almost any other. It really all depends on what you're looking for. What is not included in these calculations is action type, which is important, since a gas-operated semi-automatic shotgun (such as the Benelli M4 Tactical Shotgun) has reduced recoil over that of a pump or double in most cases. For most adults, a 12-gauge shotgun . The 1100 is the original soft-shooting gas gun. Available gauge sizes are 12, 20 and 28. The stock is designed so the exterior shell flexes outward to further dampen recoil. The only downside is having to keep the gas system clean but I have an ultrasonic cleaner for that. I agree if the shooter has the manual of arms down equally and is equally proficient in the manual of arms. It's academic a good gas-operated semi-auto can reduce recoil by as much as 30 percent versus a pump. Semiauto Shotguns. The Beretta 1301 Tactical gas-operated shotgun is a great law enforcement piece, built for close-quarters combat. For comparison, a 12-gauge shotgun's recoil is similar to a .270 Win or a .30-06 depending on the load. Really light shotguns, will kick the snot out of you. I believe the pump action to be superior to the semi-auto as a tactical shotgun. To paraphrase Mas Ayoob's police shotgun book: YOU may shoot a pump faster than I shoot a semi. just about, but it depends on the gun. This allows for a variety of hunting and shooting uses. The barrel has a ghost ring rear sight, interchangeable front sight, and a solid choke system. #1. . Averaged, we are at 32%. While the previous posters are correct about almost all gas operated semi-auto shotguns offering substantial reduction in felt recoil over pump shotguns, long recoil semi-auto shotguns actually have MORE felt recoil. When much younger I won more than a couple cases of beer emptying a Model 12 faster than a semi auto. $379.00. It can seem like a good idea, especially since many 20 gauge shotguns are smaller, lighter, and easier to handle than their larger 12 gauge siblings. Runner-Up - UTAS UTS-15 12-Gauge Pump-Action Bullpup Shotgun. . Nothing says "GET OUT!" Like the sound of a shotgun being racked. As with any firearm, the lighter the weight, the more the recoil. Further, there are compensating actions and non-compensating actions. A semi-auto shotgun has an internal spring-loaded mechanism that does all the work for you, and this offers a much faster firing rate than a pump shotgun. Pump-Action vs. Semi-Auto. And at $624, the price is right. A Model 12 will beat a Browning A5 anytime in the speed of fire department. The TriStar Tec 12 is by far the most affordable of the convertible shotguns. It is initially designed to take down upland game birds turkeys and water fowls, However, if you have the right choke which is interchangeable, it can take down deer as well. Most tend to think gas auto's as having less recoil compared to either inertia or long recoil operated guns. (rapid fielding initiative) and carried . this being said i was given a mossberg 500 though the R.F.I. The SA-28 is a 5.5-pound gas-operated auto-loader, equipped with a 24-inch barrel and has a 12.5-inch LOP. But, in a home-defense situation, it's questionable whether a reduction in recoil could play a factor in survival. however, modern semiautos arent nearly as . Same as a Winchester Model 97 - just hold the trigger back and pump. Table of Contents. There are many ways to reduce felt/perceived recoil such as proper gun fit or even better hearing protection. That pump requires more work than a semi-auto Semi-autos are often easier to handle under stress due to their design. Semiautomatics. Benelli embraced the inertia system and incorporated it in its line of semi-auto shotguns, including its iconic Super Black Eagle. Semiauto operating systems come in two major forms: gas and inertia. With practice a shooter can quickly transition a gun like the TEC-12 back and forth between semi-auto and pump mode. JTS M12AK 12 Gauge 18 Semi-Auto Shotgun. Popular Budget Option - Rock Island Armory VRBP-100 12-Gauge Semi-Automatic Bullpup Shotgun. One of the most battle-proven pump-action shotguns available today. the browning auto 5 was a serious gun, and the only reason hunters put up with its massive recoil is because it offered several quick follow up shots. The Benelli M4 is a 12 gauge, gas-operated, semi-automatic shotgun designed for tactical applications. Mar 20, 2021. Panzer Arms BP-12. The gas system the M4 uses is called the ARGO (Auto Regulating Gas Operated) system. They tend to perform fine and flawlessly even if they require minimal maintenance. ----- -----. Now if a shotgun is issued as a combat shotgun, it's about 50/50 if it will be pump vs semi, based on if the organisation has spent the money on a semi auto shotgun. 72 Posts . It's able to load 7 in the tube, 1 in the chamber, and 1 more ghost loaded into the carrier for a total of 9 shells on tap. Stoeger M3500. All the shooter needs to do is pull the trigger. It's a Semi-Auto 12-guage shotgun that has a 3.5 inch chamber. The first two are gas-operated, and the SBE2 is an inertia gun. i have a remington 870, and the recoil isnt at all unplesant. One of the most battle-proven pump-action shotguns available today (matched only by the Remington 870) the Mossberg 590 is reliable, upgradable, and an all-around performer. Gas systems use - you guessed it - the gas that's escaping from the previous shot. This means that the gun uses energy from the recoil to eject the used shell and cycle a new one into the chamber. Semi Autos have a higher starting price point but you can get some nice semi auto shotguns that are close in price to a higher end pump shotgun. Adding . It will handle shells up to the 3.5" Magnum and down to 2 3/4" for optimal versatility. Pumps do have their downside, though. The old factory shooters could do some fantastic shooting with a model 12. Semi autos typically have less felt recoil than pumps (with identical loads) but other factors such as gun weight and the type of action are contributing factors. Semi Auto Pros : Can shoot really fast. Whereas, Semi-automatic shotguns necessitate greater attention and maintenance. My philosophy is learn on the most challenging system first and everything else is easy. Its overall length of 40.75 inches makes it manageable for smaller shooters to handle. . In reality, that reduced weight can actually increase felt recoil compared . This goes through tiny ventilation holes at the bottom of the barrel, which moves a piston, which in turn cycles the action and pulls a new shell . Ammunition capacity isn't really a pro or con for either these days, as many models now offer extended feed tubes and even magazines. Check Price. With a 3-inch chamber , everything from Aguila Mini-Shells to 3-inch Magnum rifled slugs will run with aplomb and without the need for any . 40% felt recoil reduction. Weight, and stock design can have a profound affect on the felt recoil one experiences firing any gun. Before Remington refined and popularized gas operation with their ubiquitous model 1100, semi-auto shotguns basically worked using recoil operation just as they did when they were first invented. The other factor involved in felt recoil in this list is the weight of the gun. So, the inertia gun was born but the idea remained largely dormant until it was resurrected by Benelli in the late 1960s. Perhaps the most popular reasons for this are the reduction of recoil available in the gas-operated guns, and the high tech engineering that has gone into these guns over the last several years. When attempting to compare autoloading shotgun actions, it is easy to break them down into two broad categories: Recoil (short and long) and Gas operated. Reliability When the gun fires, some of the recoil energy is stored, then released in the moving parts of the gun, which spreads the kick out over a longer period of time, turning it from a sharp blow to a push. The barrel comes in at 28 inches and has 5 different choke tubes for custom shot patterns. Aug 23, 2005 Any semi auto action will offer a reduction in felt recoil over any fixed breech gun. 1 Beretta A400 Xtreme Plus - Best Recoil Duck Hunting Shotgun. The pump-action is limited to being only as fast as the operator can cycle after each shot, while the semi-automatic can be shot essentially as fast as the shooter can pull the trigger. Considerably more recoil with pumps (My Mossberg 500 kicks like a mule!) The Auto-5 is a recoil-operated shotgun, just like many you'll see on our recommendation list. Basically, there is no real difference in accuracy potential between the 870 and the 11-87. My three favorite modern 12-gauge shotguns are the Beretta A390 Silver Mallard, Winchester SX3, and Benelli Super Black Eagle 2. View at Palmetto State. If you'd like a lighter recoiling gun, consider semi-auto Follow Up Shots Much easier with semi-auto. With an 18.5-inch barrel, gas-operated semi-auto operation, 12-gauge chambering and accepting both 2-3/4- and 3-inch shells, the 940 Pro Tac has a hidden asset. Gas Operated Vs. Recoil Operated Autoloaders, Part 1. Semiautomatic shotguns. some semi autos, however, are notorious ass-kickers. 2 Browning Maxus II Wicked Wing - Most Reliable Duck Hunting Shotgun. 25% felt recoil reduction. Finally there is cost. Semi autos typically have less felt recoil than pumps (with identical loads) but other factors such as gun weight and the type of action are contributing factors. Pumps are also generally less expensive than semiauto shotgunsyou can expect to pay between $250 and $500 for most models. Some great budget pump options are the Benelli Nova, and the . Best Adjustable Option - Panzer Arms BP-12 12-Gauge Semi-Automatic Bullpup Shotgun. I don't notice any difference myself. Also since the pump in the mechanism that operates the chambering of the round, you can easier put folding and smaller stocks on the gun (semi autos sometimes extend gas tubes into the stock.) That is, if you increase the weight of a 7 pound gun by 10 % to 7.7 pounds, you will lower calculated free recoil by around 10%. I like using the guns for different times of the year and different shoots. The Kinematic Drive is ultra-reliable and harnesses recoil energy which converts into the mechanical motion needed to operate the action. There are many ways to reduce felt/perceived recoil such as proper gun fit or even better hearing protection. The Winchester Super X3 Compact makes a great youth gun. A 12-gauge shotgun generates 18 ft-lbs of recoil with a target load, and 32.8 ft-lbs of recoil with a typical waterfowl load. Long recoil semi-auto shotguns such as the original Browning Auto 5, Remington model 11 (Auto 5 . The physical pump action makes it more difficult to follow multiple targets whereas semi-auto loads your next shot right up for you. Benelli took a page out of the Glock playbook with only 3 parts of the entire gun; bolt body, inertia spring, and rotating bolt head. Generally, pump-action shotguns are more affordable than semi-automatic shotguns. Hank Sr. Check Price. They have the recoil burden when using Pump-Action shotguns. Pump Action Shotguns are preferable if recoil is not a major factor. i think most people would be more capable if they had a semi auto, however i have always prefered a pump gun. Pump is a Remington and the semi auto is a Tristar which I think is a Remington clone. the browning auto 5 was a serious gun, and the only reason hunters put up with its massive recoil is because it offered several quick follow up shots. (guns like the 20 gauge mossberg bantam pumps and break opens). Gas operated shotguns have been more or less the standard for semi-autos for about the last 50 years or so. some semi autos, however, are notorious ass-kickers. Semi-automatic shotguns are frequently expensive. apexhunter. A semi-auto shotgun has an internal spring-loaded mechanism that does all the work for you, and this offers a much faster firing rate than a pump shotgun. Benelli Montefeltro Sporting. The huge benefit the semi-auto gives you is significantly less recoil and a much higher rate of fire. Check Price. apexhunter. 3 Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 Semi-Auto Shotgun - Most Durable Duck Hunting Shotgun. SPAS 12s are now considered collector's items and run for a grand and up, and the Benelli M3 is . The M3 should best be thought of as a semi-auto shotgun with pump capability. however, modern semiautos arent nearly as . Although pump guns might have been the most popular of shotguns among waterfowlers 30, 40 and 50 years ago, semiautos dominate today. Home defense or tactical? The stronger m3500 is a recoil-operated semi-automatic hunting shotgun, it is a good all-rounder weapon that comes at around 600. Best Youth Duck Hunting Shotgun. The other factor involved in felt recoil in this list is the weight of the gun. If you're worried about the recoil of a 12 gauge shotgun being too punishing, don't overlook the 20 gauge or even in some cases, a .410 option. It also makes. 10% felt recoil reduction. But there are only 2 ways to actually reduce recoil and . But there are only 2 ways to actually reduce recoil and . Pump-Action vs Semi-Automatic Shotguns Others find the semi-auto shotgun irreplaceable. Perhaps the most popular reasons for this are the reduction of recoil available in the gas-operated guns, and the high tech engineering that has gone into these guns over the last several years. I have always. The biggest factor in felt recoil is the fit of the gun followed by shell used then weight. Although pump guns might have been the most popular of shotguns among waterfowlers 30, 40 and 50 years ago, semiautos dominate today. Also, inertia guns tend to be a little rougher recoil-wise. The modern Auto-5, like many semi-automatic shotguns, is a recoil-operated firearm. A few pros and cons of both. Of course pump shotguns are the most common . I have a few Rem 870 guns and an 11-87. Most adults can easily handle a 12-gauge's recoil with a little practice. Adding a flashlight, an extended magazine, a side-saddle with shells, a sling and a stick-on cheekpad can easily add 2 pounds to your shotgunwhich will reduce free recoil significantly. The Benelli M4 was initially designed for the Marine Corps, where it serves as the M1014. Pump Shotguns; Over/Under Shotguns; Side-by-side Shotguns; Semi-automatic Shotguns; . Setting The Woods On Fire! Almost 60 years after its. Semi-automatic shotguns are excellent in . . In other words, their semi-auto shotguns should reduce felt recoil by these percentages compared to their pump shotguns. 72 Posts . Pump-action shotguns function on a pulling method, in which you shoot and pull the fore-end to cock . just about, but it depends on the gun. The Most Affordable. Built from lightweight aluminum alloy, the humpback receiver . Throw a new hunter a semi-auto and he's likely to look like Tony Montana in Scarface. A 20-gauge is a great choice to get a youth started as it offers less recoil while giving young shooters a solid option for anything from clays on the range to late-season rooster . Benefits of a Semi-Automatic Shotgun. #2. The semi-auto nature eliminates short stroking issues and even allows a shooter to use one arm to shoot if needed. and i can sense a problem with a pump shotgun before i bring it back on target. What is not included in these calculations is action type, which is important, since a gas-operated semi-automatic shotgun (such as the Benelli M4 Tactical Shotgun) has reduced recoil over that of a pump or double in most cases. Here are my opinions: Pump gun Pros: Can shoot any shell designed to fit the gun. Pump-action shotguns function on a pulling method, in which you shoot and pull the fore-end to cock, eject the spent cartridge, and load a new shotgun shell into the chamber. Premium Duck Hunting Shotguns Overview. 50% felt recoil reduction. I have seen some good pump guys go to a semi and . When it comes to being a fighting shotgun, the semi-auto mode should be the primary mode utilized. Whether an auto shotgun is called a gas, recoil, inertia, or . Had a Win. The pump action is . Semi-Auto vs Pump Action Shotguns . Check Price. Popular home-defense pump shotguns are available from Winchester, Remington, Mossberg, Weatherby, Escort, Stoeger and other companies. Of course pump actions have disadvantages too. It's academic a good gas-operated semi-auto can reduce recoil by as much as 30 percent versus a pump. As a GENERAL rule, S/A shotguns do have less felt recoil than most pumps, if using the same shells. It also makes moving and shooting easier. Typically a gas gun will be a bit softer shooting than inertia or recoil actions and both are normally softer than a pump. Typically a gas gun will be a bit softer shooting than inertia or recoil actions and both are normally softer than a pump. Since semi-auto guns are normally heavier they help soak recoil from the start. because i know i can get it to function every time. SEMI-AUTO HUNTING SHOTGUN - WEATHERBY SA-08 DELUXE (BEST VALUE ) The SA-08 Deluxe is originally manufactured by a Turkish company and is a gas-operated model. The Benelli Montefeltro is made in Italy, but it's known as one of the most beautiful and effective shotguns in the world. The Pump-Action Tactical Shotgun. 1300 Defender Riot Pump, (a good solid shotgun) I gifted to my Son (out West) right before the Election. The other factor involved in felt recoil in this list is the weight of the gun. You can easily shoot skeet one hand unsupported and not worry about the recoil. This is a clever design in which the gun uses the energy from its own recoil to eject the used shell and load a new one into the chamber. Apr 3, 2019. Answer (1 of 21): Depends on what you're going to use it for. A pump shotgun is nice for the beginner because there's a subconscious factor working that says . #3. When compared to its equivalent, they are less inexpensive and more expensive. Then he'll be asking to borrow another box of shells. Gas shotguns take this further since they require some of the gas produced in firing to cycle their actions. IWI Tavor TS12 18.5 12 Gauge Shotgun Semi-Auto. A good pump action shotgun can be had for $500 or less. This mechanical simplicity is also beneficial in that it keeps weight to a minimum: The average defensive pump gun weighs somewhere between 5 and 7 pounds. Its a half-decent Ben Affleck flick, too. . The Beretta is for clays, ducks, pheasants, and turkeys. Browning's A5 shotgun is a recoil-operated autoloader built to be reliable, fast cycling, and soft shooting. What is not included in these calculations is action type, which is important, since a gas-operated semi-automatic shotgun (such as the Benelli M4 Tactical Shotgun) has reduced recoil over that of a pump or double in most cases. This in turn makes the gun easier to get back on target for faster follow-ups. The stock of the TEC-12 has a rubberized, finger-groove-pattern pistol grip attached. If you are a beginner or a seasoned veteran, a semi-automatic shotgun is an excellent addition to your collection. For example, the very nice Browning BPS (Pump) is $759 whereas the Winchester SX4 (Semi -auto) is one of my all time favorites for $849. If you change the amount of shot (payload) or velocity of the shell by 10%, you will affect free recoil by twice that, or 20%. The 20-inch barrel is topped off with an extended and ported choke tube, which is in the Beretta pattern. The shotgun comes covered in the Realtree Max-5 camo makes this a sweet setup. But as mentioned there are other factors in play, other than just the difference in operation of how they fire. Recoil is extremely tame, especially shooting 7/8- or -ounce loads. Rock Island VR60 Tactical 12 Gauge Shotgun. Well, not exactly, but pretty close. Click to expand. It is more versatile than the semi-auto due to its ability to cycle nearly any type of ammo. This in turn makes the gun easier to get back on target for faster follow-ups. You can order a side by side, of course you can, but the pump shotgun Mossberg 500 or this 930 semi-auto shotgun are more useful in a fight. 35% felt recoil reduction. 1ShotTV 189K subscribers Subscribe Visiting the old debate of pump-action vs semi-auto shotguns with two of the best in each category, the Remington Versa Max and Benelli SuperNova. The nice thing about the pump for the beginner is that it forces you to really focus on your shooting. . Pumps are also generally less expensive than semiauto shotgunsyou can expect to pay between $250 and $500 for most models. But you will not be able to shoot a pump faster than YOU can shoot a semi. I'd use a pump with a top folding stock to save on space if necessary. Mossberg 590 Pump Action. Still better than a pump-action, but a little heartier than a gas-operated gun. Become proficient with a pump then an auto will seem really easy.